Is Your Commercial Lease Deal as Good as It Looks?

Authored by Ella Kimler

Published 9 November 2026

In this article

The headline terms of a commercial lease are usually easy to understand: the rent, the term, the premises and the incentive. The real cost of the deal is often determined elsewhere.

For landlords and tenants, the provisions dealing with fitout, approvals, access, commencement, incentives and exit can materially change the bargain the parties thought they had agreed. Those issues also tend to emerge after money has been spent, contractors have been engaged and the commercial timetable has become difficult to move.

A good leasing deal is one that can be delivered in practice, not just one with an attractive rent or incentive. The responsibilities, dates and consequences need to be understood before either party starts committing money.

Know what you are committing to

A heads of agreement is often prepared quickly to capture the commercial deal and keep momentum. That is sensible, but the label on the document does not decide whether it is binding. The wording, the matters left unresolved and the parties’ conduct all matter.

The parties may intend the proposed lease to remain subject to formal documentation while particular provisions take effect immediately. Confidentiality, exclusivity, access, deposits, costs and preliminary works are common examples. If that distinction is not made clearly, a document intended as a commercial summary can create uncertainty about whether either party can withdraw and who bears expenditure already incurred.

Before signing a heads of agreement, identify:

  • which terms bind immediately and which remain subject to the formal lease documents
  • whether either party may begin design, approval or construction work during negotiations
  • who approves that work and who pays for it
  • the deadline for agreeing and signing the formal documents
  • what happens if the lease does not proceed

Test the value of the incentive, not just the headline number

Rent-free periods, rent abatements and fitout contributions can make a deal commercially attractive. Their value depends on the conditions attached to them and when the benefit is actually received.

A tenant may negotiate a substantial fitout contribution but still be required to fund the whole fitout upfront. Payment might only become due after practical completion, opening for trade, delivery of certificates and invoices, and confirmation that no default is continuing. That timing can create a real cash-flow gap even though the incentive looks generous on paper.

The documents should make clear:

  • the type and value of the incentive, including its GST treatment
  • whether it is provided upfront, progressively or after completion
  • which costs qualify and what evidence is required
  • how long the landlord has to assess and pay a claim
  • whether a disputed part of a claim delays payment of the undisputed balance
  • what happens on assignment, early termination or tenant default

Repayment provisions also need careful attention. They should identify the events that trigger repayment and how the amount is calculated. A clause requiring repayment should protect the landlord’s commercial position without operating as an untethered windfall. For the tenant, the practical questions are whether a clawback exists and how much may be payable at different points in the term.

Compare the incentive across every transaction document. A heads of agreement may describe an unconditional contribution, while the incentive deed or lease later introduces practical completion, trading or no-default conditions. That is not a drafting detail. It changes the economics of the deal.

Turn “landlord works” and “tenant fitout” into an actual scope

Fitout and building works are where leasing and construction risk meet. Broad descriptions such as “provide air-conditioning”, “deliver a warm shell” or “complete works to the landlord’s satisfaction” rarely tell the parties enough to price, design or enforce the obligation.

An obligation to “provide air-conditioning” says little about capacity, operating hours, controls, connection points, metering, after-hours charges or responsibility for upgrades. A tenant may design its fitout on the assumption that the existing system can support its use, only to discover that additional plant or electrical capacity is required.

For any material works, use a schedule or responsibility matrix that identifies:

  • the existing condition of the premises
  • the scope and required outcome of each work package
  • who designs, approves, carries out, pays for and maintains each item
  • the drawings, specifications and performance criteria that define completion
  • the information each party must provide, and by when
  • the inspections, testing, certificates and sign-offs required
  • what happens if the work is late, incomplete or non-compliant

This is also the point to investigate whether the premises can support the proposed use. Power, floor loading, waterproofing, exhaust, fire services, accessibility and planning restrictions can turn an apparently suitable tenancy into an expensive compromise. The lease should not be the first place those issues are considered.

Separate access, handover, commencement and trading

Early access, handover, lease commencement, rent commencement and opening for trade are different milestones. They may occur on the same day, but they serve different purposes and should be documented separately.

A delay to landlord works does not automatically extend the tenant’s fitout period or move the rent commencement date. Unless the documents say which dates move, a tenant may lose fitout time or become liable for rent before it can trade. Equally, a landlord may face an open-ended delay if commencement is tied to an outcome without a clear process or long-stop date.

A workable programme should identify:

  • when the tenant and its contractors may access the premises
  • the condition in which the landlord must hand over the premises
  • when the lease term and rent obligations begin
  • any required opening or trading date
  • which delay events justify an extension and what notice is required
  • who bears additional costs such as storage, idle time and remobilisation
  • whether an extension to one milestone also moves the long-stop date

These mechanics need to work as a sequence. Each clause may make sense on its own, yet read together the tenant can access before the premises are ready, rent can start before handover, or a long-stop date can expire while an agreed extension is still running.

Plan for the deal not proceeding

Pre-lease arrangements often depend on development approval, finance, agreed works, third-party consent or another condition essential to the transaction. The condition should be defined by reference to the commercial outcome required, not simply the receipt of a document.

For example, development approval may be obtained but be commercially unusable because it restricts operating hours, access or capacity, or requires expensive additional works. The documents should identify what approval is acceptable, who must pursue it, the level of effort required, the cooperation each party must provide and the deadline.

If a condition cannot be met, the agreement should provide a practical pathway: additional time, revised works, waiver, a cost adjustment or termination. Termination rights should be clear about who may exercise them, the notice required and whether that party must first have complied with its own obligations.

By that stage, the parties may have paid consultants, provided security, ordered materials or completed work on site. The documents should therefore deal expressly with:

  • design and consultant fees
  • deposits, security and bank guarantees
  • ownership and payment for completed work and materials
  • removal, reinstatement and make-good
  • incentives already paid or accrued
  • rights to use drawings and other design documents
  • the obligations that survive termination

An exit clause is not pessimistic drafting. It lets the parties make early commitments knowing the downside if the transaction cannot be completed.

The commercial check before you sign

Before committing to a commercial lease or pre-lease arrangement, step back from the headline rent and ask whether the transaction documents answer the operational questions that will determine whether the deal works in practice:

  • Can the premises support the intended use?
  • Are the works sufficiently defined to be priced and delivered?
  • Does the incentive arrive when the tenant needs the cash?
  • Do the access, handover, commencement and rent dates operate consistently?
  • If a critical approval or work package is delayed, who bears the time and cost?
  • If the deal does not proceed, what happens to the money spent, work completed and security provided?

Those questions are much easier to resolve while the parties still have options. Once works have started or the opening date is approaching, the same issues become more expensive and the negotiating leverage changes.

If you are negotiating a commercial lease, heads of agreement or agreement for lease, Batch Mewing Lawyers can review the documents against the commercial deal and identify where risk or cost is left unresolved before you commit.

Have a question?

If you’re unsure how this applies to you, feel free to send us a message.

Related Articles

Liquidation can leave a project without funding, licence or a contractor to finish the job. This guide covers whether the works can continue, what to do whichever way the insolvency runs, and how to protect security and records.

How can we help?

Whether you're facing an issue or planning ahead, we’re here to help you move forward. Share a few details using the form to get started.